What I Use Instead of Black Walnut Stain (Natural)

Make your own wood stain from black walnuts! This water-based stain is natural, easy to make, and a simple way for anyone to enhance the beauty of wood.

DIY Black Walnut Stain

Are you looking for natural ways to enhance the beauty of your wood projects? This DIY black walnut stain is the solution! It’s made with simple ingredients like black walnuts and water. It’s easy to make, easy to apply, and doesn’t have any stinky fumes like oil-based stains.

You may also enjoy How to Stain Wood with Coffee and How to Stain Wood with Tea

This tutorial contains affiliate links to supplies and tools. Purchases made using these links help support the Saws on Skates website and allows me to share more projects and tips with you. There is no cost to you for using these links. Visit my site policies for more information.

Why Use Black Walnuts to Stain Wood?
What Do You Need to Make Black Walnut Stain?
How Do You Preserve Black Walnut Stain?
What Kind of Wood Can You Stain With Black Walnuts?
How Do You Prepare the Wood?
How Do You Apply the Black Walnut Stain?
How Long Does the Stain Need to Dry Before Applying Another Coat?
How Many Coats of Black Walnut Stain Can You Apply?
How Do You Seal the Wood?
How to Make Black Walnut Stain:
- Option #1 Walnut Hull Powder
- Option #2 Whole Walnuts

Why Use Black Walnuts to Stain Wood?

There are several benefits to using black walnuts to make a homemade stain rather than buying a traditional wood stain.

❕ ALLERGY WARNING: This DIY Stain contains tree nuts.

1. Natural

This DIY stain is made with just two simple ingredients, black walnuts, and water.

2. Safer

Traditional oil-based wood stains can be dangerous. When we read the instructions for an oil-based stain we’ll see that they’re combustible and that they need to be used in a well-ventilated area.

This DIY stain is made with water. A water-based stain like this is not combustible. It also doesn’t have any stinky fumes like an oil-based stain.

This means we can safely use it indoors. We don’t need to worry about combustion or making sure that we have a lot of ventilation.

3. More Control

If you’ve ever used a store-bought stain you know that the color can sometimes be unpredictable.

This DIY black walnut stain gives us more control over the color of our project.

The final color is more predictable because each coat adds a small amount of color.

4. Use as a Pre-Stain Wood Conditioner

We can also use black walnut stain to pre-condition wood before we apply an oil-based stain. This is a great solution for those difficult-to-stain woods like pine.

Store-bought pre-stain wood conditioners help to prevent blotchiness and allow the wood to absorb stain more evenly.

Related: What I Use Instead of Wood Conditioner

Both a store-bought wood conditioner and a homemade black walnut stain can help prevent blotchiness, but the real difference is the way they accept stains.

It appears to me store-bought wood conditioners reduce blotchiness by preventing the stain from soaking deeply into the wood.

In my experience, wood treated with a store-bought conditioner produces a lighter stain color than I expected. To me, wood treated with a DIY black stain produces a darker, richer color.

Left: This side was treated with one coat of black walnut stain and one coat of Rust-Oleum Dark Walnut oil-based stain. The color is darker, richer and more even.

Right: This side has one coat of Rust-Oleum Dark Walnut oil-based stain.

Showing how to use a DIY black walnut stain as a wood conditioner

Back to Table of Contents

What Do You Need to Make Black Walnut Stain?

We only need a few simple things to make a black walnut stain. First, we’ll need some black walnuts. We can either use black walnuts from our yard or store-bought walnut hull powder.

I don’t have black walnuts in my yard so I bought this walnut hull powder.

Walnut hull powder being used to make a DIY black walnut stain

We’ll also need some water and a container (like a mason jar) to keep it in.

💡 TIP: Be sure to use gloves when working with a black walnut stain. Black walnuts will stain hands and the stain can be difficult to remove.

Back to Table of Contents

How Do You Preserve Black Walnut Stain?

Black walnuts are food-based, so this stain could spoil and become moldy.

There are a few things we can do to help it last longer.

First, I added white vinegar to the black walnut stain.
Second, I refrigerated the stain mixture to help it last longer.

💡 TIP: When you’re ready to stain a project, pour the amount of stain you think you’ll need into a small container. Then work from that small container. This will reduce the chances of contaminating the jar where you keep your stain.

Back to Table of Contents

What Kind of Wood Can You Stain With Black Walnuts?

We can use this black walnut stain on just about any kind of wood like pine, poplar, oak, maple, etc. I used this homemade stain on pine for all of the samples in this tutorial.

💡 TIP: All woods take stain differently. As with any stain, it’s a good idea to test it on some sample boards before using it on your project. This way, you can be sure it will produce the color you’re looking for.

Three pine boards that have been stained with a DIY black walnut stain

Back to Table of Contents

How Do You Prepare the Wood?

We should sand the wood to prepare it for the stain. I sanded the samples in this tutorial with 100 grit, 120 grit, and 150 grit sandpaper.

Water-based products, like this black walnut stain, raise the grain of the wood. This means the surface of the wood is no longer smooth. There are two ways to deal with this.

One way is to apply water to the wood before applying the water-based stain. Dip a rag in water and wipe it on the surface of the wood. When the wood is dry, lightly sand with 220 grit sandpaper. Then remove the sanding dust with a ShopVac and apply the walnut stain.

The other way is to sand the wood after applying the water-based stain. This is what I chose to do for my project. Once the final coat of walnut stain was dry, I lightly sanded the wood with 220 grit sandpaper to smooth the surface. Then I removed the sanding dust with a ShopVac.

The end grain of the wood tends to pull in more stain than the rest of the board. This is especially true when using a water-based stain like this.

One way to help prevent this from happening is to sand the end grain to a higher grit than the rest of the board. For my project, I used a sandpaper assortment (similar to this one) to sand the end grain with 180 grit, 220 grit, 240 grit, 280 grit, and finished sanding with 320 grit sandpaper.

Back to Table of Contents

How Do You Apply the Black Walnut Stain?

I used an inexpensive 1″ foam craft brush to apply the walnut stain on some sample pieces of pine. But after the second coat, I noticed this brush was leaving lap marks on the wood.

I switched to this paint brush (my favorite brush!) for the remaining coats of stain and it didn’t leave lap marks. I would recommend using a quality brush to apply the stain.

Back to Table of Contents

How Long Does the Stain Need to Dry Before Applying Another Coat?

I allowed the stain to dry for about two hours before applying another coat.

Back to Table of Contents

How Many Coats of Black Walnut Stain Can You Apply?

For this tutorial, I applied five coats of stain to some sample pieces of pine.

Five coats of DIY black walnut stain applied to pine boards

I mentioned earlier that this is a water-based stain. I should also mention that water will remove the stain.

This is important to remember for two reasons:

First, projects stained with walnuts need to be sealed.
Second, you’ll want to avoid using a water-based sealer as this may remove the stain as it’s being applied.

Water can remove this DIY black walnut stain

Back to Table of Contents

How Do You Seal the Wood?

For this tutorial, I tested the walnut stain with five different top coats. These top coats included beeswax polish, furniture wax, oil-based polyurethane, Bob’s Miracle Finish, and shellac.

I’ve been using this water-based Polycrylic on many of my recent projects. I didn’t test Polcrylic on the walnut stain because, as I mentioned earlier, water removed some of the walnut color from the test piece. So I presumed a water-based product like Polycrylic would remove the stain.

This DIY beeswax polish removed some of the stain color and left the wood looking a little dull.

This furniture wax also removed some of the stain color and left the wood looking dull.

This semi-gloss oil-based polyurethane removed some of the stain color but added depth to the wood and added a little shine.

Bob’s Miracle Finish removed some of the stain color but added depth to the wood and added a little shine.

This shellac was the only top coat that didn’t remove the stain color. It also added depth to the wood and added a little shine.

I should mention that wax-free shellac can be used under any other top coat. In other words, we can first apply a wax-free shellac and then apply any other top coat like Polycrylic, polyurethane, etc.

Back to Table of Contents

How to Make Black Walnut Stain

There are two ways we can make a stain with black walnuts. We can either use whole walnuts or walnut hull powder.

I used powder to make my stain so I will focus on that method for this tutorial. Click here for how to make stain with whole walnuts.

Black Walnut Stain with Walnut Hull Powder

Supplies

Walnut Hull Powder (I used this one)
Water
White Vinegar
Mason Jar
Bamboo Skewer

Tools

Measuring Spoons
Measuring Cups
Disposable Gloves
Paint Brush (I used this one)

Step 1. Make the Stain

Add 1 tablespoon of walnut hull powder to a mason jar.

Boil 1-½ cups of water and carefully add it to the mason jar. I stirred the mixture with a bamboo skewer.

You can use something else to stir the mixture like a spoon, etc. but keep in mind that it may become stained by the mixture.

When the mixture was cooled, I added a ½ cup of white vinegar to help preserve the stain.

Pouring walnut hull powder into mason jar to make homemade black walnut stain

Step 2. Prepare the Wood

See How to Prepare the Wood for more details.

Step 3. Apply the Black Walnut Stain

I applied the stain to the wood with this paint brush.

I allowed the first coat of stain to dry for two hours. Then I applied four more coats of stain. Each coat was allowed to dry two hours before applying the next.

Using a brush to apply homemade black walnut stain to some pieces of pine.

Step 4. Seal the Stain

For my project, I chose to first apply a coat of wax-free shellac and then three coats of this matte-finish water-based Polycrylic. I sanded with 220 grit sandpaper between each coat and removed the sanding dust with a ShopVac.

See How Do You Seal the Wood? for more information.

Back to Table of Contents

Black Walnut Stain with Whole Walnuts

There are two ways to make black walnut stain with whole walnuts. We can either boil them or just let them steep in the water for a few days.

With either method, we’ll need about 15-20 walnuts. The husks of the nuts need to be removed. Be sure to wear gloves to remove the husks because your hands will become stained and the stain will be difficult to remove. When the husks are removed, put the walnuts in a cheesecloth bag.

Next, we’ll need a large stockpot. Be sure to use one you don’t care about because the walnuts may stain the stockpot.

Place the cheesecloth bag in the stockpot and add about a gallon of water.

Boil Method

For the boil method, allow the walnuts to soak for about 24 hours. After 24 hours, boil for 1-2 hours. Carefully remove the cheesecloth bag and allow the pot to cool.

When the pot is cool, strain any debris, and pour the stain into a mason jar.

Add about ½ cup of white vinegar and store the stain in the refrigerator.

Steep Method

For the steeping method, allow the walnuts to soak for about two days. After two days remove the cheesecloth bag. Strain any debris and pour the stain into a mason jar.

Add about ½ cup of white vinegar and store the stain in the refrigerator.

Final Thoughts

Enhance the beauty of your wood projects with this DIY black walnut stain. It’s made with simple ingredients like black walnuts and water. It’s easy to make, easy to apply, and doesn’t have any stinky fumes like oil-based stains.

Thank you for stopping by. If you enjoyed this tutorial, would you please take a moment and pin it to Pinterest? I’d really appreciate it!